HEAVY METALS RISK ASSESSMENT FOR CONSUMPTION OF WILD MEDITERRANEAN MUSSELS MYTILUS GALLOPROVINCIALIS LAMARCK, 1819 ALONG SAMSUN COASTS OF THE BLACK SEA
PDF

Keywords

estimated daily intake
target hazard quotients
risk index

How to Cite

Bat, L., Yardım, Öztekin, Arıcı, E., Hasançavuşoğlu, Z., & Öztekin, A. (2023). HEAVY METALS RISK ASSESSMENT FOR CONSUMPTION OF WILD MEDITERRANEAN MUSSELS MYTILUS GALLOPROVINCIALIS LAMARCK, 1819 ALONG SAMSUN COASTS OF THE BLACK SEA. Pakistan Journal of Marine Sciences, 32(2), 129–144. Retrieved from https://pakjmsuok.com/index.php/pjms/article/view/143

Abstract

The present study aimed to determine the concentration of metals in the soft tissue of wild mussels in coastal of Samsun and to assess human consumption. Using inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry, the quantities of cadmium, mercury, lead, copper, iron, and zinc in Mytilus galloprovincialis were measured. The heavy metals found in Mediterranean mussels are arranged in the following ascending order: Cd < Hg < Pb < Cu < Fe < Zn. Concentrations of toxic metals were safe according to European Commission guidelines and the Ministry of Agriculture, Forestry and Fisheries. According to the estimated daily intake (EDI), eating Mediterranean mussels poses no risks. The target hazard quotients (THQs) in metals are also found <1, which implies no threat to consumers. In conclusion, the current study confirmed that the concentration of heavy metals in the Mediterranean mussels is safe for people intake in terms of their toxicity.

PDF

References

Altug, G. and N. Guler, 2004. The levels of heavy metals in some organisms and seawater samples from the Istanbul Strait, Dardanelles and Black Sea, Turkey. Istanbul University, J. Fish. Aquat. Sci. 17: 47-55.

Andreev, G. and V. Simeonov, 1992. Interphase distribution and accumulation of elements in the marine environment of the Black Sea. Toxicol. Environ. Chem. 36(1-2): 99-104. (https://doi.org/10.1080/02772249209357831).

Andreev, G., V. Simeonov and S. Stoikov, 1994. Occurrence and distribution of heavy metals in benthic organisms from the Black Sea. Toxicol. Environ. Chem. 45(3-4): 167-171. (https://doi.org/10.1080/02772249409358080).

Arıcı, E. and L. Bat, 2016. Heavy metal levels in Mediterranean mussel Mytilus galloprovincialis from the Turkish Black Sea coast as biomonitor and potential risk of human health. 2nd International Conference on One Medicine One Science, April 24-27, 2016. University of Minnesota, Minneapolis, USA.

Bakan, G. and H. Büyükgüngör, 2000. The black sea. Mar. Poll. Bull. 41(1-6): 24-43.

Bakan, G. and H.B. Özkoç, 2007. An ecological risk assessment of the impact of heavy metals in surface sediments on biota from the mid‐Black Sea coast of Turkey. Int. J. Environ. Stud. 64(1): 45-57.

Baltas, H., M. Sirin, G. Dalgic, E.Y. Bayrak and A. Akdeniz, 2017. Assessment of metal concentrations (Cu, Zn, and Pb) in seawater, sediment and biota samples in the coastal area of eastern Black Sea, Turkey. Mar. Poll. Bull. 122(1-2): 475-482. (https://doi.org/10.1016/j.marpolbul.2017.06.059).

Bat, L. and E. Arıcı, 2018. Chapter 5. Heavy Metal Levels in Fish, Molluscs, and Crustacea From Turkish Seas and Potential Risk of Human Health. In: Holban AM, Grumezescu AM. (Eds.) Handbook of Food Bioengineering, Volume 13, Food Quality: Balancing Health and Disease. Elsevier, Academic Press, (ISBN: 978-0-12-811442-1). pp. 159-196. (http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/B978-0-12-811442-1.00005-5).

Bat, L. and E.Y. Özkan, 2019. Heavy metal levels in sediment of the Turkish Black Sea coast. In: I. Management Association (Ed.), Oceanography and Coastal Informatics: Breakthroughs in Research and Practice. Hershey, PA: IGI Global. pp. 86-107. (doi:10.4018/978-1-5225-7308-1.ch004).

Bat, L., 2019. Concentrations of toxic elements in mussels Mytilus galloprovincialis as bioindicator of coastal pollution. International Biodiversity and Ecology Sciences Symposium Proceedings (BIOECO 2019), Istanbul, Türkiye.

Bat, L., A. Gundogdu, M. Ozturk and M. Ozturk, 1999. Copper, zinc, lead and cadmium concentrations in the Mediterranean mussel Mytilus galloprovincialis Lamarck, 1819 from the Sinop coasts of the Black Sea. Turk. J. Zool. 23(4): 321-326.

Bat, L., A. Öztekin, E. Arıcı and F. Şahin, 2021. Mytilus galloprovincialis and metal contaminants: health risk assessment from Sinop coasts. KJFHC. 7(4): 13-21. (https://doi.org/10.13106/kjfhc.2021.vol7.no4.13).

Bat, L., A. Öztekin, F. Şahin, E. Arıcı and U. Özsandıkçı, 2018b. An overview of the Black Sea pollution in Turkey. MedFAR. 1(2): 67-86.

Bat, L., and H.C. Öztekin, 2016. Heavy metals in Mytilus galloprovincialis, Rapanavenosa and Eriphia verrucosa from the Black Sea coasts of Turkey as bioindicators of pollution. Walail. J. Sci. Technol. 13(9): 715-728.

Bat, L., E. Arıcı and A. Öztekin, 2018c. Human health risk assessment of heavy metals in the Black Sea: evaluating mussels. Cur. World Environ. 13(1): 15-31. (https:// doi.org/10.12944/CWE.13.1.03).

Bat, L., E. Arıcı, A. Öztekin, Ö. Yardım and F. Üstün, 2018d. Use of the Mediterranean mussel Mytilus galloprovincialis Lamarck, 1819 from Sinop coasts of the Black Sea as Bio-monitor. Int. J. Mar. Sci. 8(5): 44-47. (https://doi.org/10.5376/ijms.2018.08. 0005).

Bat, L., E. Arıcı, M. Sezgin and F. Sahin, 2016. Heavy metals in edible tissues of benthic organisms from Samsun coasts, South Black Sea, Turkey and their potential risk to human health. J. Food Health Sci. 2(2): 57-66. (https://doi.org/10.3153/JFHS16006).

Bat, L., E. Arıcı, Ö. Yardım and A. Öztekin, 2017. Heavy Metals in the Mediterranean mussel Mytilus galloprovincialisLamarck, 1819 from Sinop coasts of the Turkish Black Sea coast as bio-monitor. The 3rd International Symposium on EuroAsian Biodiversity, 05-08 July 2017, Minsk, Belarus.

Bat, L., F. Şahin and A. Öztekin, 2018e. Toxic elements in edible mollusks from Igneada coasts of the Black Sea, Turkey. (https://doi.org/10.13106/kjfhc.2018.vol4.no3.22).

Bat, L., F. Sahin, M. Sezgin, S. Gonener, E. Erdem and U. Ozsandıkcı, 2018a. Fishery of Sinop coasts in the Black Sea surveys. Eur. J. Biol. 77(1): 18-25. (doi: 10.26650/EuroJBiol.2018.388175).

Bat, L., F. Üstün and O. Gökkurt Baki, 2012. Trace element concentrations in the Mediterranean mussel Mytilus galloprovincialis Lamarck, 1819 caught from Sinop coast of the Black Sea, Turkey. Open Mar. Biol. J. 6: 1-5.

Bat, L., M. Sezgin, F. Şahin, Z. Birinci Özdemir and D. Ürkmez, 2013. Sinop city fishery of the Black Sea. Mar. Sci. 3(3): 55-64. (DOI: 10.5923/j.ms.20130303.01).

Bat, L., M. Sezgin, H.H. Satılmış, F. Şahin, F. Üstün, Z. Birinci-Özdemir and O. Gökkurt-Baki, 2011. Biological diversity of the Turkish Black Sea coast. Turk. J. Fisher. Aquat. Sci. 11: 683-692.

Bat, L., O. Gökkurt, M. Sezgin, F. Üstün and F. Sahin, 2009. Evaluation of the Black Sea land based sources of pollution the coastal region of Turkey. Open Mar. Biol. J. 3(1): 112-124.

Belivermis, M., Ö. Kılıç and Y. Çotuk, 2016. Assessment of metal concentrations in indigenous and caged mussels (Mytilus galloprovincialis) on entire Turkish coastline. Chemosphere, 144: 1980-1987. (https://doi.org/10.1016/j.chemosphere. 2015.10.098)

Bologa, A.S., M. Apas, A. Cociasu, E. Cuingioglu, V. Patrascu, I. Pecheanu, V. Piescu and L. Popa, 1998. Present level of contaminants in the Romanian Black Sea sector. IAEA-SM-354/26. 30(41): 58-63.

Boran, M. and H. Karacam, 1997. Trace element levels of mussels (Mytilus galloprovincialis Lamarck, 1819) in Trabzon coastline. EgeJFAS, 14(3-4): 336-344. (in Turkish).

BSGM, 2023. T.R. The Ministry of Agriculture and Forest General Directorate of Fisheries and Aquaculture 2022 Fishery products statistic. (http:// www. tarim. gov. tr/BSGM.)

Bucşe, A., O.C. Pârvulescu, D. Vasiliu and M. Mureşan, 2022. The contents of some trace elements (As, Br, Cu, Hg, Se, and Zn) in Mytilus galloprovincialis mussels from Agigea Port, Romania. Front. Mar. Sci. 9: 1-13. (https://doi.org/10.3389/ fmars.2022.899555).

Bucşe, A., O.C. Pârvulescu, D. Vasiliu, N. Lupașcu and C. Voica, 2021. Levels of heavy metal concentration in M. galloprovincialis mollusc species from NW Black Sea (Romania). U.P.B. Sci. Bull., Series B. 83(3): 51-60.

Catherine, T., M. Vanessa, S. Evangelia, C. Valentina, R. Andreja, A.A. Rana, C. Susana, F. Serena, K. Alisa, L. Yiota, H. Ioannis, O. Andra and T. Daniela, 2016. Biochemical biomarker responses to pollution in selected sentinel organisms across the Eastern Mediterranean and the Black Sea. Environ. Sci. Pollut. Res., 23(2): 1789-1804. (https://doi.org/10.1007/s11356-015-5410-x).

Cevik, U., N. Damla, A.I. Kobya, V.N. Bulut, C. Duran, G. Dalgic and R. Bozaci, 2008. Assessment of metal element concentrations in mussel (Mytilus galloprovincialis) in Eastern Black Sea, Turkey. J. Hazard. Mater.160(2-3): 396-401. (https://doi.org/ 10.1016/j.jhazmat.2008.03.010).

Coatu, V., A. Oros, D. Ţigănuș, G. Shtereva and L. Bat, 2016. Assessment of the contaminants in biota from the Western Black Sea basin in respect with MSFD requirements in the frame of the MISIS Project. Cercetări Marine, 46: 82-97.

Commission Regulation (EC), 2006. Setting Maximum Levels for Certain Contaminants in Foodstuffs. No 1881.

Damir, N., D. Danilov, A. Oros, L. Lazăr and V. Coatu, 2022. Chemical status evaluation of the Romanian Black Sea marine environment based on benthic organisms’ contamination. Cercetări Marine, 52(1): 52-77. (https://doi.org/10.55268/CM.2022. 52.52).

Das, Y.K., A. Aksoy, R. Baskaya, H.A. Duyar, D. Güvenc and V. Boz, 2009. Heavy metal levels of some marine organisms collected in Samsun and Sinop Coasts of Black Sea, in Turkey. J. Anim. Vet. Adv. 8(3): 496-499.

Demina, L.L. and D.M. Budko, 2014. Trace metals in carbonate biomineralization by the example of bivalvia Mytilus spp. from the Black Sea. (in Russian). Geol.-Mineral. Sci. Fundament. Res. 11: 2185-2189. (https://doi.org/10.1134/S0001437016010033).

Dökmeci, A.H., 2017. An assessment of the heavy metals in wild mussels Mytilus galloprovincialis from the Marmara Sea coast of Tekirdağ, Turkey. 15th International Conference on Environmental Science and Technology (CEST 2017), Rhodes, Greece.

Egorov, V.N., G.E. Lazorenko, N. Mirzoyeva, N.A. Yu., Stokozov, S.K. Kostova, L.V. Malakhova, A.V. Pirkova, S.I. Arkhipova, N.F. Korkishko, V.N. Popovichev, O.V. Plotitsyna and L.V. Migal, 2006. Content of 137Cs, 40K, 90Sr, 210Po radionuclides and some chemical pollutants in the Black Sea mussels, Mytilus galloprovincialis Lam. Mar. Environ. J. 3: 70-78.

FAO (Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations), 2010. The Food Consumption Refers to the Amount of Food Available for Human Consumption as Estimated by the FAO. Food Balance Sheets.

Gorinstein, S., S. Moncheva, F. Toledo, P. Arancibia-Avila, S. Trakhtenberg, A. Gorinstein, I. Goshev and J. Namiesnik, 2006. Relationship between seawater pollution and qualitative changes in the extracted proteins from mussels Mytilus galloprovincialis. Sci. Total Environ. 364(1-3): 251-259. (https://doi.org/10.1016/ j.scitotenv.2005.06.013).

Gorinstein, S., S.T. Jung, S. Moncheva, P. Arancibia-Avila, Y.S. Park, S.G. Kang, I. Goshev, S. Trakhtenberg and J. Namiesnik, 2005. Partial characterization of proteins from mussel Mytilus galloprovincialisas a biomarker of contamination. Arch. Environ. Contam. Toxicol. 49(4): 504-510. (https://doi.org/10.1007/s00244-004-0238-2).

INCDM, 2008. State of the Marine and Coastal Environment Report, National Institute of Marine Research and Development, (in Romanian). Online at: http://www.rmri.ro/RMRI/RaportStareaMediului/RaportStareaMediului_2008-1.pdf.

INCDM, 2009. State of the Marine and Coastal Environment Report, National Institute of Marine Research and Development, (in Romanian). Online at: http://www.rmri.ro/RMRI/RaportStareaMediului/RaportStareaMediului_2009-1.pdf.

INCDM, 2010. State of the Marine and Coastal Environment Report, National Institute of Marine Research and Development, (in Romanian), Online at: http://www.rmri.ro/RMRI/RaportStareaMediului/RaportStareaMediului_2010.pdf.

Jitar, O., C. Teodosiu, A. Oros, G. Plavan and M. Nicoara, 2015. Bioaccumulation of heavy metals in marine organisms from the Romanian sector of the Black Sea. New Biotechnology, 32(3): 369-378. (https://doi.org/10.1016/j.nbt.2014.11.004).

Kapranov, S.V., N.V. Karavantseva, N.I. Bobko, V.I. Ryabushko and L.L. Kapranova, 2021. Element contents in three commercially important edible mollusks harvested off the southwestern coast of Crimea (Black Sea) and assessment of human health risks from their consumption. Foods. 10(10): 2313. (https://doi.org/10.3390/ foods10102313).

Kuplulu, O., G. IplıkcıogluCıl, S.D. Korkmaz, O. Aykut and G. Ozansoy, 2018. Determination of metal contamination in seafood from the Black, Marmara, Aegean and Mediterranean Sea metal contamination in seafood. J. Hell. Vet. Med. Soc. 69(1): 749-758. (https://doi.org/10.12681/jhvms.16400).

MAFF (The Ministry of Agriculture, Forestry and Fisheries), 1995. Monitoring and Surveillance of Non-Radioactive Contaminants in the Aquatic Environment and Activities Regulating the Disposal Wastes at Sea. Directorate of Fisheries research, Lowestoft, Aquatic Environment Monitoring Report, No.44.

Manev, I., V. Kirov and H. Neshovska, 2020. Heavy metals accumulation in Black Sea ecosystems: seawater, sedİment, algae, benthİcorganİsms. Trad. Mod. Vet. Med. 2(9): 88-99.

Oros, A. and M.T. Gomoiu, 2010. Comparative data on the accumulation of five heavy metals (cadmium, chromium, copper, nickel, lead) in some marine species (molluscs, fish) from the Romanian sector of the Black Sea. Cercetari Marine, 39: 89-108.

Oros, A. and M.T. Gomoiu, 2012. A review of metal bioaccumulatıon levels in the Romanian Black Sea biota during the last decade - A requirement for implementing Marine Strategy Framework Directive (Descriptors 8 and 9). J. Environ. Prot. Ecol. 13(3A): 1730-1743.

Oros, A., 2009. The contributions to acknowledging the consequences of the heavy metals pollution on the coastal marine ecosystems from the Romanian littoral of the Black Sea. University Ovidius of Constanta, Romania, PhD Thesis. (https:// doi.org/10.13140/RG.2.2.17178.03522).

Oros, A., I. Pecheanu and R. Mihnea, 2003. Some aspects concerning trace metals bioaccumulation in Mytilus galloprovincialis along the Romanian Black Sea coastal area. J. Environ. Prot. Ecol. 4(4): 850-856.

Oros, A., R. Mihnea and I. Pecheanu, 2002. Considerations regarding trace metal presence in marine ecosystem components along the Romanian Black Sea coastal zone. Cercet. Mar. 34: 197-208.

Ozturk, M.A., 1991. Study on the two invertebrate and two algae species for their heavy metal build up on their respective levels those tend to live in Sinop Province’s inner and outer harbours or coves (in Turkish). Ondokuz Mayıs University, Turkey PhD Thesis. pp. 85.

Petisleam, T., I.V. Popescu, V. Ciupina and M. Belc, 2006. Considerations regarding Cu and Ni determination from marine environmental samples of Black Sea using FAAS. Rom. Journ. Phys. 52(3-4): 441-444.

Peycheva, K., V. Panayotova, R. Stancheva, L. Makedonski, A. Merdzhanova, N. Cicero, V. Parrino and F. Fazio, 2021. Trace elements and omega-3 fatty acids of wild and farmed mussels (Mytilus galloprovincialis) consumed in Bulgaria: human health risks. Int. J. Environ. Res. Pub. Health. 18(19): 10023. (https://doi.org/10.3390/ijerph181910023).

RAIS (Risk Assessment Information System), 2023. University of Tennessee. Available from https://rais.ornl.gov/index.html. (accessed 10.10.2023).

Rodioru, D.M., A. Oros and L. Lazar, 2016. Assessment of the heavy metals contamination in bivalve Mytilus galloprovincialis using accumulation factors. J. Environ. Prot. Ecol. 17(3): 874-884.

Roméo, M., C. Frasila, M. Gnassia-Barelli, G. Damiens, D. Micu and G. Mustata, 2005. Biomonitoring of trace metals in the Black Sea (Romania) using mussels Mytilus galloprovincialis.Water Research, 39(4): 596-604. (https://doi.org/10.1016/j.watres. 2004.09.026).

Simeonova, P., D. Simeonov, L. Spassov and V. Simeonov, 2013. Determination and statistical interpretation of toxic metals content in mollusks and snails from Black Sea. Bulg. J. Chem. 2(3): 105-14.

Stancheva, M., V. Ivanova and K. Peycheva, 2012. Determination of heavy metals in Black Sea Mytilus galloprovincialis and Rapanavenosa. Script. Sci. Medic. 44(2): 27-30. (http://dx.doi.org/10.14748/ssm.v44i2.353).

Stanciu, G., M. Mititelu and S. Gutaga, 2005. Pesticides and heavy metals determination in marine organisms from Black Sea. Environ. Sci. 50(64): 123-126.

Strungaru, S.A., M. Nicoara, C. Teodosiu, D. Micu and G. Plavan, 2017. Toxic metals biomonitoring based on prey-predator interactions and environmental forensics techniques: A study at the Romanian-Ukraine cross border of the Black Sea. Mar. Poll. Bull. 124(1): 321-330. (https://doi.org/10.1016/j.marpolbul.2017.07.052).

Temerdashev, Z.A., I.I. Eletskii, A.A. Kaunova and I.G. Korpakova, 2017. Determination of heavy metals in Mytilus galloprovincialis Lamarck mussels using the ICP-AES method (in Russian). Analyt. Cont., 21(2): 116-124. (https://doi.org/10.15826/ analitika.2017.21.2.009).

Tepe, Y. and N. Süer, 2016. The levels of heavy metals in the Mediterranean mussel (Mytilus galloprovincialis Lamarck, 1819); Example of Giresun coasts of the Black Sea, Turkey. Ind. J. Geo-Mar. Sci. 45(2): 283-289.

Topcuoglu, S., Ç. Kırbasoglu and N. Gungor, 2002. Heavy metals in organisms and sediment from Turkish coast of the Black Sea, 1997-1998. Environ. Int. 27(7): 521-526. (https://doi.org/10.1016/s0160-4120(01)00099-x).

Turk Culha, S., L. Bat, M. Culha, A. Efendioglu, M. Andac and B. Bati, 2007. Heavy metals levels in some fishes and molluscs from Sinop Peninsula of the Southern Black Sea, Turkey. Rapp. Comm. Int. Mer. Medit. 38: 323.

U.S. EPA (United States Environmental Protection Agency), 2023. Regional Screening Level (RSL) Summary Table (TR=1E-06, HQ=1) May 2023. (https://www.epa.gov/ risk/regional-screening-levels-rsls-generic-tables.). (accessed 10.10.2023).

Unsal, M., M. Dogan, Ü. Atac, S. Yemencioglu, S. Akdogan, Y. Kayikci and M. Aktas, 1992. Determination of heavy metals in the marine organisms of economical importance in the central and eastern Black Sea. Ministry of Agriculture and Rural Affairs Trabzon Fisheries Research Institute. Project No: DEBAG–18/G: pp. 52. (in Turkish).

Unsal, M., N. Cagatay, Y. Bekiroglu, N. Kıratlı, N. Alemdag and E. Sari, 1998. Trace element pollution in the Black Sea. Ministry of Agriculture and Rural Affairs Trabzon Fisheries Research Institute, Project No. YDEBÇAG-456/G- 457/G, 70pp. Mersin/Turkey (in Turkish).

UNSCEAR (United Nations Scientific Committee on the Effects of Atomic Radiation), 2010. Sources and effects of ionizing radiations, UNSCAR 2008 Report to General Assembly with Scientific Annexes, vol. I. United Nations Publications, New York.

Üstün Odabaşı, S., Z. Ceylan, İ. Şentürk, F. Akbal, G. Bakan and H. Buyukgungor, 2022. Investigation of spatial and seasonal variation of water quality along the mid-Black Sea coast (from Sinop to Ordu) of Turkey, by multivariate statistical. Regional Studies in Marine Science, 50: 102169. (https://doi.org/10.1016/j.rsma.2022. 102169).

Creative Commons License

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.

Copyright (c) 2023 Levent Bat, Öztekin Yardım, Elif Arıcı, Zeynep Hasançavuşoğlu, Ayşah Öztekin